The Uncommitted Driver: Why Fewer Applicants Isn’t the Real Crisis

A Crisis We Don’t Talk About Enough

The trucking industry loves to talk about the “driver shortage.” You’ve seen the headlines. You’ve sat in the meetings. Maybe you’ve even repeated the phrase yourself.

But here’s the truth: we don’t just have a shortage problem, we have a commitment problem.

You know the type. A driver fills out an application. Looks good on paper. Passes the first call. Shows up to orientation. And then poof. Gone. No explanation. No call. Just another seat left empty, another wasted week, another recruiting budget burned.

That’s not just turnover. That’s the uncommitted driver, and it’s quietly draining fleets more than any applicant shortage ever could.

I recently tackled this on The Rig on Wheels Show in an episode called “Fewer Applicants, More Turnover: The Uncommitted Driver Market.” You can catch the full discussion on iHeart here. But in this article, I want to take you deeper into why this trend is growing, how it impacts recruitment, retention, and safety, and what fleets can do to fight back.

The Bigger Picture: More Than a Driver Shortage

We’ve been sold the idea that the industry’s biggest challenge is simply not enough applicants. But raw application numbers don’t tell the story.

Today, fleets are still receiving plenty of applications. The problem is that fewer of those applicants are qualified, committed, and willing to stay.

Compare that to two or three years ago. Back then, a solid job ad with clear pay and home time could fill an orientation class in days. Now? You might see the same number of apps come in, but most are “drive-by drivers.” They’re applying to five, ten, or fifteen fleets at once. They’re testing the waters. They’re not committing.

Applicant count is a misleading metric. It makes recruiters feel busy, but it doesn’t measure intent. A hundred apps don’t matter if only five are real.

“One committed driver is worth more than fifty ghost applications.”

Signs of the Uncommitted Driver

So how do you spot these drivers before they burn your time and money?

Here are the common red flags:

• Job-hopping every few months with no clear reason.

• Vague or missing work history, especially in recent years.

• Duplicate applications under different emails or phone numbers.

• Passive or detached answers during phone screens (“Whatever’s fine…”).

• Negative attitude bashing past companies instead of owning their choices.
  

I’ve seen it firsthand. A driver looked flawless on paper. Clean MVR, right experience, great tone on the first call. We invested the time, got him to orientation, and within days? He ghosted. Why? Another fleet offered “newer trucks.”

It wasn’t about equipment. It was about commitment. He never had it.

👉I shared a story like this on the podcast episode, but it bears repeating here: our real challenge isn’t finding drivers; it’s finding the ones who actually want to be here.

Why Commitment Matters More Than Numbers

Let’s zoom out. What happens when fleets hire uncommitted drivers?

• Recruitment Costs Balloon: Ads, recruiter hours, and background checks are all wasted.

• Retention Tanks: Early quits mean constant backfilling.

• Safety Risks Rise: Disengaged drivers are more likely to skip pre-trips, cut corners, or ignore training.
  

The cost of an uncommitted driver isn’t just the empty truck. It’s the ripple effect across your whole operation.

That’s why I say commitment beats convenience. A convenient hire fills the seat for a week. A committed hire builds your brand for years.

Building Commitment Before Day One

The good news? You don’t have to wait until a driver’s first load to test their loyalty. Retention starts before orientation.

Here’s how:

1. Communicate Early and Often

Speed matters, but so does depth. Follow up quickly, but also set clear expectations. If it’s home weekly, define exactly what “weekly” means.

2. Create an Onboarding Structure

Even small fleets can look professional with a simple system:

• One point of contact from “you’re hired” to the first load.

• A welcome packet with names, photos, and resources.

• A clear day-by-day orientation plan.
  

3. Use Peer Mentors

Pair new hires with experienced drivers. It builds belonging faster than any policy manual.

4. Make Orientation About Culture, Not Just Compliance

Don’t just throw policies at them. Bring leadership in. Share stories from your best drivers. Make them feel part of something.

👉 These are the kinds of strategies I dig into with fleets in my book Competing with Giants and The Driver Magnet Kit tools that help smaller carriers attract and keep the right drivers without bleeding budget.

Safety at Risk: Why Commitment Matters Beyond Hiring

Here’s where it gets serious.

Uncommitted drivers don’t just hurt recruiting numbers. They put safety on the line.

Think about pre-trips. A committed driver spends those 15 minutes checking lights, brakes, and tires like their life depends on it because it does.

An uncommitted driver? They kick a couple tires and roll.

And that shortcut can turn into a CSA violation, a blown steer tire, or worse.

This isn’t just about individual behavior; it’s about culture. If dispatchers roll their eyes at safety delays or managers pressure drivers to “just get it there,” you’re building a culture where safety is optional. And optional safety is dangerous.

Safety First Checklist for Fleets with High Turnover

If your turnover is high, and let’s be real, most fleets struggle here, you’ve got to reinforce safety even harder.

• Make training interactive. Don’t let drivers zone out.

• Spot disengagement early. Back-row body language is a warning sign.

• Use peer accountability. Pair new hires with “safety champions.”

• Reward reporting. Treat defect reports as wins, not hassles.

• Audit your culture. Would a driver here feel comfortable shutting down for the weather?
  

If the answer is no, you’ve got work to do.

Commitment vs. Convenience: My Lesson Learned

Let me get personal for a second.

In my early recruiting days, I made the mistake of chasing convenience. If the app checked the boxes, I pushed it through.

I learned quickly that convenience costs.

I hired drivers who saw me as convenient, too, until another fleet dangled something shinier. Those short-term “wins” turned into revolving-door losses.

Now I know: commitment is everything.

When you get the right drivers in the right seats, you’re not just filling trucks. You’re building a fleet legacy.

Commitment is the Competitive Edge

So let’s call it like it is: fewer applicants aren’t what’s sinking fleets. It’s the lack of commitment.

Applicant counts don’t measure intent. Ghost apps don’t move freight. And uncommitted drivers don’t build culture.

Commitment does.

👉If this resonated with you, listen to the full episode of The Rig on Wheels Show on iHeart here. I dig even deeper into how recruitment, retention, and safety all tie back to commitment.

And if your fleet is struggling to find those committed drivers, check out:

• Rig on Wheels Recruiting Services for fleets that want ready-to-roll drivers without the ghosting.
  

• The Driver Magnet Kit is a $47 toolkit packed with job post templates, captions, and scripts that attract the right drivers.
  

• Competing with Giants is my guide for small fleets to go head-to-head with the big carriers without overspending.
  

The future of trucking doesn’t belong to the biggest fleets.

It belongs to the fleets that know how to win commitment.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

If you are interested in any CDL Class A Truck Driving Jobs

Contact us today! 281-968-3100​​.

Driver Application Link

To learn more about Rig on Wheels Broker and Recruitment Services.

Email questions to recruiting@rigonwheels.com

Follow us.